News from PC Magazine: Microsoft Reveals Longhorn Details
By Michael J. Miller
Microsoft is slowly but surely lifting the veil of secrecy surrounding its next version of the widely used Windows operating oystem, code-named Longhorn.
Recently, I got a firsthand look at Longhorn’s new search capabilities, as well as many more details about what end users can expect from the still-in-development OS, courtesy of Jim Allchin, group vice president of Microsoft’s Platforms Group. Allchin also revealed that hardware developers at this month’s Windows Hardware Engineering Conference (WinHec) will be given a release designed for writing device drivers, and that a full beta version with user interface will come out a few months later.
Allchin described Longhorn as nothing less than “the OS platform for the next ten years.” It’s on track for Beta 1 release this summer and final release for the 2006 holiday season. Although the Avalon graphics system, Indigo Web services system, and WinFS file system (now slated to ship sometime after Longhorn) have gotten the most attention, Microsoft’s design goals focus on six key points, Allchin says:
1. It just works
2. Safe and secure
3. Easy to deploy and manage
4. Client experiences—at work, at home, and on the go
5. The right server for your business
6. OS platform for the next ten years
The article goes farther and it does have some interesting points. These six bullets made me think, and I feel the need to react.
1. It just works
Like Plug and Play, right? Desirable, even noble. Show me. I’ll believe it after I see it on a system I manage. When users in the real world say it just works, then this can be used for a description. Until then, it’s just a wish.
2. Safe and secure
I hope so. I’ll believe it when I see it. My personal concern is that Microsoft understands Layer 7 of the OSI model, but not the underlying foundation layers. So often things in MS applications make assumptions or place requirements un the underlying network. As the worldwide web becomes the worldwide OS, decoupling the OS from the network is less and less practical. Show me.
3. Easy to deploy and manage
Like Plug and Play, right? Is there an echo in here? Again, when users in the real world say it just works, then this can be used for a description. Until then, it’s just another fantasy.
4. Client experiences—at work, at home, and on the go
Huh? Does this say something? I have client experiences with Microsoft already. Some good, some not good, some disastrous. I just think this is filler that says nothing. Or it says it might work some of the places you’ll need it.
5. The right server for your business
Says who? In many ways, this ties back to the OSI model and how applications behave with the underlying network layers. Microsoft doesn’t always understand that even the OS is an application at layer 7 and there are other dependencies (read plays well with others). So again, I say show me.
6. OS platform for the next ten years
Nobody will ever want a computer in the home.
Nobody will ever outgrow a 20Mb hard drive.
Nobody will ever ened more than 640k of RAM.
See Moore’s Law. Some folks have already learned this lesson. Take advantage of lessons learned.
I remain ambivalent about Longhorn, in large part because it doesn’t matter.
Any new OS will be an enabler and a disabler
Some things we do today won’t be possible in a new environment. Some things we can’t do today will become possible. Until the OS is in the hands of users and system adminstrators, we don’t know what the good, bad or ugly will be.
There are a few things I feel confident predicting about Longhorn. It will consume more disk space than any PC-based OS ever seen. It will eat more system resources. It will need more RAM. More, more more. It won’t run on my old Toshiba P90 laptop with 16M RAM and a 720M hard drive. I can pretty much guarantee it won’t.
In the real world, in the IT Garage-like real world, Longhorn is still so far into the future that the talk is pure fantasy. Fantasy and illusion. Smoke and mirrors. And while it may be cool beans, it doesn’t exist in our real world, and won’t until it’s tested, released, gains traction and proves itself.
Just rambling thoughts…