After testing the Nokia N-Series for some time now, across the N73, N93 and N80i, I have to say the single biggest problem is the poor memory management in the Symbian OS.
I’ve noticed comparable problems across the N-series phones I’ve tested, and I don’t believe it’s related to the caliber of software that’s been developed. I think it’s all in the OS.
The other day I noted some problems I’ve had with fring and why I removed it. Since then, I replaced the 1G MiniSD in my N80i with a 2G MiniSD. Because I’d installed Shozu on the memory card, I had to reinstall.
First off, I got a note from someone I trust who said enver ever install an app on a memory card. Why? Can’t Nokia figure out how to do it right? I’ve installed numerous apps on the SD card in my Treo 700w and they work just fine. No problem at all.
When I reinstalled Shozu, I got a notice that it was a minor upgrade (dot release level). Since that time, it just plain doesn’t work. The phone exhibits the same painfully slow performance problem it did with fring. Shozu doesn’t work. I’ve reinstalled and deleted at least 20 times. To phone. To card. Delete and clean install. Upgrade install over the top. The bottom line is that the N80i can’t handle it any longer.
Damn shame. I really like Shozu. It works flawlessly on my Treo where I have no use for it and don’t want it, but on the Nokia’s? All it does is make them useless.
Again, I don’t think it’s the application. I think it’s shoddy memory management.
Unfortunately, this third party add-on is what made the N80i it’s most useful to me. Without it, well, the N80i is just one more thing in my pocket. Will I use it? Sure, I’ll continue testing. But now I feel I can’t install any third party apps on the N-series. I’ve had too many failures, and they’ve all been related to memory management (mismanagement or poor management).
I’m disappointed, because without third party software enhancements, the Nokia N-series is a set of nice, albeit expensive phones, that I just won’t use long term. I have them as part of the Nokia Blogger Relations program, and I will certainly continue to test and use them as long as I have them. But I’m deeply disappointed.
Truth be told, if Nokia told me I could keep them, I’d give them all away and stick with my Treo 700w at this point. They just dont live up to my needs. They’re too usntable and unpredictable. And while many things work wonderfully and are truly impressive, I find them unstable. A tweak here or a third poart add-on their, and they’re off in the twilight zone. I can’t accept that kind of performance in a mobile device that’s my primary tool for business. And for me my mobile is my primary tool.
Color me disappointed today.
Technorati Tags: Nokia, N-Series, N80i, N73, N93. memory management problems